should prisoners be allowed to vote essay
The court held by twelve to five votes that there had been a violation of article 3 of Protocol 1.
Why not break laws it if there is no punishment?
They are prisoners; of course they shouldn’t have the right to vote. Removal from society means removal from privileges of society, amongst which is the right to vote for one’s representative. The limitations imposed on the right to vote were legitimate as it was considered part of a prisoners punishment that he loses those rights.
Prisoners should receive the basic human needs of food, clothing, medical attention and exercise. Persuasive Essay: Should Prisoners Be Allowed To Vote?
Disclaimer: This work has been submitted by a law student.
By walkeraulisha, Are You on a Short Deadline?
The court gave dismissed the application on the following grounds. Not rehabilitation, which is only for people that have short term Jail time. Although some categories of prisoners retained the right to vote, the bar affected a wide range of offenders and sentences.
As I believe right to vote is a right not a privilege and people are sent to prison to lose their liberty not their identity.
The three claimants had applied for their names to be added to the electoral register but were refused by the virtue of section 3 of the Representation of the People Act 1983 which states “A Convicted Person during the time he is detained in a penal institution in pursuance of his sentence… is legally incapable of voting at any parliamentary or local election”. It had regard to the fact that it stripped a large group of people to vote, that is applied automatically irrespective of length of sentence or the gravity of the offence, and that the result were arbitrary and anomalous, depending on the timing of the elections.
Furthermore, both sides of the argument must be taken into balance before a final decision is taken as this decision may impact the entire future of a country. Some may, have children and decide to protect them, and not all people are criminals as some people may argue.
It was mentioned that prison is meant to be rehabilitative, but not all rison sentences are meant to be rehabilitative but purely punitive. As I believe right to vote is a right not a privilege and people are sent to prison to lose their liberty not their identity. Article 3 of the First Protocol states that “The High Contracting Parties undertake to hold free elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot, under conditions which will ensure the free expression of the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature.
The chamber found that the exclusion from voting imposed on convicted prisoners in detention was disproportionate.
Prisoners are not allowed to vote in any election given the fact that they lose their freedom once they are convicted.
This is said to be incompatible with section 3 of the Representation of the People Act 1983. You are now a felon, depending on your sentence, whom has to abide by the rules of the prison. The government did right by denying them their right to vote. If an individual is to be disfranchised that must be in pursuit of a legitimate aim….
It is ironic that the Government has declared a commitment to promoting universal suffrage,58 is concerned about underregistration among the electorate, and has introduced a new bill this session,59 which, is designed inter alia to improve electoral registration, but at the same time it continues to exclude convicted prisoners.
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have your work published on the UKDiss.com website then please: Our academic writing and marking services can help you!
The right to vote was not a privilege, and the presumption was in favour of universal suffrage.
Life without parole and death row inmates are not in there for rehab. It cannot be seen as a punishment for prisoners as in the present case the court ruled that the applicant had completed the … there was no logic in denying him the right to vote.
If you are in Jail at the time of an lection you lose the right/privilege to vote. All the rights should be vanished from the ones that are being imprisoned Fact of the matter outside the prison walls or fences is free world of bylaws. Therefore they were denied the right to vote and issued proceedings in the High Court under section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998, seeking a declaration that this provision was incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.
This matter is mostly based on opinions but such an important decision cannot be taken lightly. This is not an example of the work produced by our Law Essay Writing Service. 6th Aug 2019 You can view samples of our professional work here. I’m not going to Just throw this stink-bomb out there; everyone knows the only political party who wants this is the Democrats, because they would receive 99% of the criminal vote. The consequences for failing to implement this ruling can result in United Kingdom having to pay out compensation to prisoners which will result in tens and thousands pounds of taxpayer’s money being wasted plus litigation fees on top. Many other countries allow prisoners to vote. Reference this. As it can be seen that the U.K has taken a number of positive steps towards universal suffrage. When you are apart of the society, you are allowed the privileges the citizens of the society have. 1 is not absolute, there is room for implied limitations, and states must be given a margin of appreciation.24, The chamber held that the means employed were disproportionate, The right to vote is a right not a privilege.
Matt Prater Actor, Chaya Sarathkumar Wikipedia, Viking Fridge Ice Maker Not Working, Thane Of Falkreath Console Command, Alex Apocalypse Costume, Warfare 1917 Hacked, Fatigue Diarrhée Et Douleurs Musculaires, Abc 7 News Anchors Los Angeles, Describe The Relationship Between Karma Dharma And Reincarnation, Paquita La Del Barrio Age, Is Tysha Alive, Syracuse Weather 15 Day, Pressure In Front Of Neck Throat, The Kite Runner Guilt Essay, Smoke Grass Meaning, Choppy Choppy Your Pee Pee Gif, A Lot Meaning In Urdu, Roblox Script Executor, Pes 2013 Next Season Patch 2020 Update V1 0, Kenai Spur Highway Accident Today, Spanish Inflation Silver, Amourence Lee For City Council 2020, Mansion Of The Living Dead Full Movie, Spinus Tristis Meaning, Hound Pet Skyblock, Olx Venta De Ganado, Hitman Sniper 2 Apk, Windham County Vt Registry Of Deeds, Is Jill Griffiths Dead, Yom Kippur Symbols, Ben Rappaport Michael Rapaport Related, Black Doctors In Phoenix, Wand Of Healing 5e Price, Priscilla Faia Portuguese, 7500 True Story, Hoover Fh50150 Recovery Tank, Louder With Crowder, Nick Cave Wife, Printable Mm Ruler, Why Is The Bill Of Rights Important Essay, Marlin Model 60 Upgrades, Netgear R7000 Firmware Downgrade, Amino Aesthetic Bio, Iron On Patches For Hats, Piaggio Zip Exhaust, Number Plate Font Generator, How Does Mno2 Act As A Catalyst, 9 Weeks Pregnant No Heartbeat Seen But Embryo Still Growing, Severed Head Prop, Randy Rhoads Burbank Home, Cody Nickson Height, Will Cullen Hart, How To Remove Refrigerator Door With Water Line, Wan Jie Xian Zong Season 4, How To Jump 2 Wire Ac Pressure Switch, No Name Brand Font, Fiona Viotti Sports Illustrated, Dave Sorensen Plane Crash Idaho, Kinsey Movie Reaction Paper, Doggy Bgs Wiki, Persona 4 Golden Shadow, Myla Rae Seder, Sandcastle Game Friv, Did The Vikings Smoke Tobacco, Catherine Paiz And Austin Mcbroom Net Worth, Basic Math Clothing, Zion Hört Die Wächter Singen Piano Sheet Music Pdf, Felicia Wiley Horowitz, Jaws Unleashed Online, Strider Ar 75, Cody Alan Williams Net Worth, Directv Soccer Channels Today, National Road Max St Tire Review, Financial Situation Secure Marginal Inadequate, Legend Of Zelda Hack Rom Gba, T6r Console Commands Bo2 Zombies, Bannister Wma Duck Hunting, Traditional Métis Jewelry,